Dark social, explained: where B2B buyers actually decide
Most B2B buyers have a favourite vendor before they talk to anyone in sales. Here is where that preference forms, why your dashboards miss it, and what to do about it.
In short
- Dark social is the sharing and peer advice that happens in places analytics cannot see: private messages, email, group chats, communities, podcasts and events. Alexis Madrigal coined the term in The Atlantic in 2012.
- In 6sense's 2025 study, buyers made first contact 61% of the way through the journey, and their top-ranked vendor won 77% of the time. In Europe, first contact came at 58%.
- Attribution software credits the last click, not the conversation that created the demand. Ask every lead how they heard about you and read the answers next to your software data.
Dark social is the sharing and advice that happens where your analytics cannot see it: private messages, email threads, group chats, closed communities, podcasts and conversations at events. It matters in B2B because that is where buyers form their shortlist. By the time a prospect fills in your contact form, most of the decision has usually been made in places your dashboards never recorded.
What dark social means, and where the term comes from
The term was coined by the journalist Alexis Madrigal in an October 2012 article for The Atlantic called "Dark Social: We Have the Whole History of the Web Wrong" [1]. Working with data from the analytics company Chartbeat, he noticed that a large share of visitors arrived on individual articles with no referrer, the piece of data that tells a website where a visitor came from. People were not typing long article addresses by hand. They were clicking links that friends had sent by email or instant message, and analytics tools had no way to label them.
Madrigal called this invisible sharing "dark social". At The Atlantic, it accounted for 56.5% of social traffic to individual stories. Across a wider set of sites in Chartbeat's data, almost 69% of social referrals were dark, against roughly 20% from Facebook [1].
Since then, B2B marketers have stretched the term. Today it usually means more than links without a referrer. It covers any influence on a purchase that leaves no trace in your systems: a recommendation in a Slack community, a WhatsApp message between two CTOs, a podcast episode, a hallway chat at a conference.
Why so much B2B research happens out of sight
B2B purchases are expensive, involve several people and are hard to reverse. Buyers reduce that risk by asking people they trust, and those conversations rarely happen on public platforms. The usual places:
- Peer conversations: a call with a former colleague who already uses the product.
- Private messages and group chats: LinkedIn messages, WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram, internal Slack or Teams channels.
- Communities: professional Slack and Discord groups, forums, Reddit threads, alumni networks.
- Podcasts and video: a founder interview heard on the commute, then mentioned in a meeting.
- Events: conference talks, dinners, meetups, industry association gatherings.
Gartner's research points the same way. In a survey of 771 B2B buyers, published in 2023, buyers said they valued third-party interactions, such as customer references, reviews and conversations with outside experts, 1.4 times more than digital interactions with suppliers [2]. Two years earlier, Gartner reported that 43% of B2B buyers would prefer not to interact with a sales rep at all [3]. If buyers trust each other more than they trust you, and would rather not speak to your sales team, they will do most of their homework without you.
How far buyers get before they talk to you
The most useful recent data comes from 6sense, a B2B software company that surveys buyers each year. Its 2025 report draws on around 4,000 buyers in North America, Europe, the Middle East, Africa and Asia-Pacific [4]. A companion analysis covers 945 buyers in Belgium, France, Germany, the Netherlands and Sweden [5].
| Finding (6sense, 2025) | Global | Europe |
|---|---|---|
| Point in the journey when buyers first contact a seller | 61% | 58% |
| First contacts started by the buyer, not the seller | 79% | 80% |
| Vendor ranked first before contact goes on to win | 77% | 75% |
| Average buying cycle | 10.1 months | 9.8 months |
Sources: global figures [4], European figures [5].
Two more figures from the global report: 94% of buyers had ranked their shortlist in order of preference before speaking to any seller, and they evaluated about five vendors on average [4].
There is some good news. First contact now comes earlier than in previous years, at 61% of the journey rather than about 69% [4]. But the pattern holds. Buyers do most of the work alone, they usually call you rather than the other way round, and the vendor they already prefer usually wins.
There is a second reason to care about the quiet part of the journey. Research by the B2B Institute at LinkedIn and Professor John Dawes of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute suggests that only about 5% of B2B buyers are in the market at any given time [6]. The other 95% will buy later, and when they do, they largely rely on memory. The peer conversations happening today decide which names they remember.
Why attribution software misses it
Attribution software tries to assign credit for a sale to the marketing touches that came before it. It can only count what it can see. Five things get in the way:
- No referrer. Links opened from email, messaging apps and many mobile apps arrive without source data, so analytics files them as "direct" traffic [1].
- No click at all. A podcast, a talk or a colleague's recommendation creates demand without generating a single trackable visit.
- Long journeys with many people. With buying cycles of around ten months [4], cookies expire, people switch devices, and the person who fills in your form is often not the one who first heard about you.
- Consent and privacy rules. In the EU, many visitors decline analytics cookies, so part of every journey is missing from the start.
- Last-touch bias. Credit goes to the final visible step, often a branded search or a retargeting ad, even when the real cause was a conversation weeks earlier.
The result is a dashboard that overvalues the bottom of the funnel. Teams then cut the activities that create demand, because those activities never show up in the report.
What a B2B tech company can practically do
You cannot track dark social, but you can influence it and measure it indirectly.
Be the name peers mention
Buyers recommend what they can explain. Make your positioning simple enough to repeat in one sentence: who you serve, which problem you solve, and why you are different. Then be present, without pitching, in the three to five places where your buyers actually talk.
Give people something worth forwarding
Dark social runs on forwarding. Publish things a buyer would send to a colleague with a note saying "worth a look": a benchmark, an honest comparison, a calculator, a checklist for a hard decision. A good test is whether it still helps someone who never buys from you.
Ask "How did you hear about us?"
Add a required, open-text field to your demo and contact forms. Do not use a drop-down menu; a fixed list hides the answers that matter, such as a podcast name or a specific community. Ask again on the first sales call and record it in your CRM.
Read self-reported and software attribution side by side
Self-reported attribution means what buyers tell you, in their own words, about how they found you. Do not replace your software data with it; compare the two. When software says "direct" or "branded search" and buyers say "a friend in a founders' group", you have found your dark social. Review both every month and give budget to the channels buyers name, not only the ones your software can see.
Make founders visible
People talk about people more readily than about companies. Founders who share what they have learned, appear on podcasts, speak at events and answer questions in communities give peers something specific to pass on. Keep it useful and consistent rather than promotional.
What to do on Monday
- Add an open-text "How did you hear about us?" field to every form, and make it required.
- Ask your sales team to record the answer from every first call in the CRM.
- List the five communities, newsletters, podcasts or events where your buyers talk, and pick two to show up in each month.
- Plan one piece of content this quarter that a buyer would forward to a colleague.
- Start a monthly review that puts self-reported sources next to your software attribution.
At Wardenclyffe Venture Studio, this kind of groundwork is part of how we set up go-to-market with B2B technology companies across the Western Balkans, DACH and wider Europe. If you would like to compare notes, read more about how the studio works.
Sources
- Dark Social: We Have the Whole History of the Web Wrong. The Atlantic, 2012. theatlantic.com
- Gartner Marketing Survey Finds B2B Buyers Value Third-Party Interactions More Than Digital Supplier Interactions. Gartner, 2023. gartner.com
- Gartner Says B2B Sales Organizations Need to Give Customers a Seller-Assisted Digital Buying Experience. Gartner, 2021. gartner.com
- 2025 B2B Buyer Experience Report. 6sense, 2025. 6sense.com
- How European B2B Buying Journeys Differ (and Don't) From the Rest. 6sense, 2025. 6sense.com
- The 95:5 rule is the new 60:40 rule. Marketing Week, 2021. marketingweek.com
Share

