Skip to content
Go-to-market

Why growth stops when ad spend stops

Performance ads mostly capture buyers who were already looking. When the budget stops, so does the growth. Here is what the research says, and what to build instead.

In short

  • Sales activation produces quick results that fade; brand building works more slowly, but its effects last and add up. For B2B, Binet and Field's guide is roughly 46% brand, 54% activation.
  • Up to 95% of business buyers are not in the market at any given moment, so ads that only chase people ready to buy now reach a small slice of your future customers.
  • Growth you own comes from clear positioning, being known in buyer networks, content worth forwarding and a pipeline system, measured in pipeline and revenue rather than clicks.

Growth stops when ad spend stops because performance ads mostly rent the attention of the few buyers who were already about to buy. When you stop paying, that attention goes to whoever is still paying, and nothing has changed in the minds of the much larger group who will buy later. Growth that keeps going comes from being known and remembered before buyers start looking.

What the research says about short-term and long-term effects

In 2013 Les Binet and Peter Field published The Long and the Short of It with the IPA, the UK's Institute of Practitioners in Advertising [1]. They analysed nearly a thousand campaigns in the IPA's effectiveness databank and separated two kinds of marketing:

  • Sales activation: messages designed to make someone act now: click, download, book a demo. They produce a sharp lift in sales that decays quickly and leaves brand perceptions unchanged [1].
  • Brand building: messages designed to be remembered, so that your name comes to mind when the need appears. The effects grow slowly, last longer, and over time also make buyers less sensitive to price [1].

For the consumer brands in their data, the best results came from roughly 60% of budget on brand building and 40% on activation [1].

In 2019 Binet and Field repeated the analysis for business-to-business marketing in The 5 Principles of Growth in B2B Marketing, published by the B2B Institute, a think tank funded by LinkedIn [2]. The pattern held. Activation "is unlikely to be very memorable, so the effects don't last long", while brand effects "last longer and so accumulate over time" [2]. Their B2B guide was around 46% brand and 54% activation, and they stress it is a guiding principle, not a precise target [2].

A later B2B Institute study with WARC and Lions, The B2B Effectiveness Code (2021), looked at how B2B marketers actually behave [3]. It found the sector skews heavily towards short-term, rational, tightly targeted campaigns, with campaigns running longer than three years almost absent from the data. It repeats the 46/54 split as the ideal B2B mix [3].

So the problem is not that performance marketing fails. It works, but only for as long as you pay for it.

Most of your buyers are not in the market right now

Professor John Dawes of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute set out the reason in a 2021 report: up to 95% of business clients are not in the market for many goods and services at any one time [4]. The logic is simple. If companies change a supplier about once every five years, roughly 20% are in the market over a year, and about 5% in any given quarter [4]. Dawes calls the 95% a heuristic rather than a precise rule. The B2B Institute, which worked with Dawes on the research, popularised the "95:5 rule" in Marketing Week the same year [5].

This changes how you read your ad reports. A performance campaign, by design, speaks to the 5%. The other 95% don't click, not because the ad is bad, but because they don't need you yet. By click metrics that audience looks like waste. In practice, it is next year's pipeline.

Why paid search and performance ads mostly harvest demand

A search ad appears when someone types a query. They type the query because the need already exists. So the ad doesn't create that demand; it competes for it, alongside every rival bidding on the same words.

Dawes adds two findings that matter here. People largely rely on memory when they buy, rather than searching. And when they do search, they strongly prefer brands they already know; less familiar brands get lower click-through rates [4]. In other words, familiarity built earlier makes your ads work better later.

Think of it as planting and harvesting. Performance ads harvest. If nothing was planted, the harvest depends entirely on the budget, and when the budget stops, the curve drops. We call this rented growth.

Push and pull: the Edison way and the Tesla way

We use two names as shorthand. They are a metaphor, not a history lesson.

The Edison way is push. More ads, more cold email sequences, more sales hires. Energy goes in, results come out, and when the input stops, the output stops.

The Tesla way is pull. You build a field around the company. Buyers come to you because they already know who you are, a peer mentioned you, or someone forwarded something you wrote. It takes longer to charge, but it keeps working when you are not pushing.

Most companies need both. Pull without any push is slow; push without any pull is expensive and fragile. The table shows the difference.

Rented growth Owned growth
Main engine Paid ads, cold outreach, bought lists Positioning, reputation, referrals, useful content
Who it reaches The ~5% of buyers in market now The ~95% who will buy later, as well as today's buyers
Speed Fast to start Slow to start
When spending stops Results fall quickly Results keep building on what exists
Cost over time Tends to rise as rivals bid for the same buyers Tends to fall as familiarity grows
What you measure Clicks, cost per lead Pipeline, win rate, revenue, unprompted awareness
Who owns the asset The ad platform Your company

What the shift looks like for a B2B technology company

1. Positioning people can repeat. A buyer should be able to say in one sentence who you serve and which problem you solve. Ehrenberg-Bass calls the situations that trigger a purchase "category entry points" [4]. List yours, and make sure your message is tied to them.

2. Be known in buyer networks. Many B2B decisions are shaped in conversations between peers: industry groups, communities, events, partners, podcasts, LinkedIn. Pick the few places where your buyers actually talk, and show up there consistently, without pitching.

3. Content worth forwarding. Write for the person who is not buying this quarter. Benchmarks, honest comparisons, practical guides, simple calculators. The test: would a buyer forward it to a colleague with "worth a look"? Binet and Field's advice for B2B is to start reaching potential buyers long before they come to market [2].

4. A pipeline system. When the 5% do arrive, nothing should leak. Define your pipeline stages, who owns each lead, how fast you respond and what the next step is. Brand work raises the number of people who come to you; the system turns them into revenue.

5. Measure pipeline and revenue, not clicks. Track pipeline created, win rate, sales-cycle length and revenue. Add a few slower signals: how many buyers name you unprompted, branded search, inbound referrals. The B2B Effectiveness Code describes a ladder of effects, from campaign response up to sales pipeline value and long-term brand and business growth [3]. Clicks sit on the lowest rung.

6. Commit for longer than a quarter. Brand effects build over years, not weeks [1]. If the plan changes every quarter, nothing has time to accumulate.

Keep the performance budget; just stop expecting it to do the whole job.

A practical checklist

  • Can a buyer repeat your positioning in one sentence?
  • Have you written down the situations that make someone need a product like yours?
  • What share of your budget reaches people who are not buying this quarter? Compare it with the roughly 46% B2B guide [2], as a reference rather than a rule.
  • Do you publish at least one thing each quarter that someone would forward?
  • Are you consistently present in the three to five places where your buyers talk?
  • Does every lead enter a defined pipeline with an owner and a next step?
  • Does your monthly report show pipeline and revenue, not only clicks and cost per lead?
  • Have you committed to the plan for at least a year?

If you want help building this kind of system, Wardenclyffe Venture Studio works with B2B technology companies on positioning, pipeline and sales systems, for a one-off setup fee and then a success fee. You can read more about how we work.

Sources

  1. The Long and the Short of It: Balancing Short and Long-Term Marketing Strategies. IPA, 2013. ipa.co.uk
  2. The 5 Principles of Growth in B2B Marketing. The B2B Institute (LinkedIn), 2019. business.linkedin.com
  3. The B2B Effectiveness Code: Creativity and effectiveness in B2B marketing from 2010-2021. The B2B Institute at LinkedIn, with WARC and Lions, 2021. business.linkedin.com
  4. Advertising effectiveness and the 95-5 rule: most B2B buyers are not in the market right now. Ehrenberg-Bass Institute for Marketing Science, 2021. marketingscience.info
  5. The 95:5 rule is the new 60:40 rule. Marketing Week, 2021. marketingweek.com

Share

LinkedIn

Strong product, slow sales?

Tell us what you've built. If it's a fit, we'll build the go-to-market around it, and most of our fee will depend on the results.